Log on |  Join ($$)
	search discussion:

These ratings are posted by site users; this content is not intended to be investment advice, nor does it represent the opinion of, counsel from, or recommendations by Bankinvestor.com

Average returns on Jimmybodeen's ratings: Rating Avg. Return Annualized Key: - : rated buy, stock went down + : rated sell, stock went up +/- : rated hold + : rated buy, stock went up - : rated sell, stock went down strong buy -3.04% (over an avg. of 1648.60 days) -0.67% buy +43.99% (over an avg. of 3943.00 days) +4.07% hold +23.95% (over an avg. of 225.90 days) +38.70% sell +19.66% (over an avg. of 205.50 days) +34.92% strong sell +12.51% (over an avg. of 262.00 days) +17.43% -- See performance by time period -- All ratings made during the year 2002 All ratings made during the year 2003 All ratings made during the year 2004 Ratings made during Nov, 2002 Ratings made during Dec, 2002 Ratings made during Jan, 2003 Ratings made during Apr, 2003 Ratings made during Jun, 2003 Ratings made during Jan, 2004 Ratings made during Mar, 2004 Ratings made during Apr, 2004

Jump to rating for: ACAS   BCSB   CFFN   CFSL   CHEV   CHFN   CSBK   FPTB   GPT   HCBK   MCBF   MO   PFS   PHSB   RFBK   RSLN   SERC   SFFS   SYNF   TONE   WAWL   WGBC  

NOTE: areas highlighted in blue indicate that this user is sharing the highlighted information with their private group ONLY

-- ACAS --
ACAS	Nov. 22 2002, 11:47 AM ET Rating closed on May. 15 2003, 10:52 AM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Buy
ACAS performance: Price near date of rating (11/22/2002): 20.23 Price near end of rating (05/15/2003): 24.49 Price change: +4.26 Dividends collected: 1.36 Gain/Loss over 173 days: +5.62 +27.78% Annualized Gain/Loss: +58.61% I know managment is smart and proven, but I've never seen anyone survive a sustained economic downturn in this business. I never bought the stock until now because I felt there wasn't a sufficient margin of safety. But if JJR, Histream, Horn, Sysop and others like it, how can you stay on the sidelines? Was this user's rating of 'ACAS' helpful to you?
back to top
-- BCSB --
BCSB	Jan. 10 2003, 11:19 AM ET Rating changed on Jun. 4 2003, 10:27 AM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Sell
BCSB performance: Price near date of rating (01/10/2003): 13.65 Price near end of rating (06/04/2003): 16.39 Price change: +2.74 Dividends collected: 0.125 Gain/Loss over 144 days: +2.87 +20.99% Annualized Gain/Loss: +53.20% This MHC has never made even average earnings. It's possible to grow the size of a bank and earnings at the same time. BCSB has not figured out how this is done. It's ok to hold some shares if you are buying a "basket" of MHC's, but I'd commit my major dollars to the better performers. Was this user's rating of 'BCSB' helpful to you?
back to top
BCSB	Jun. 4 2003, 10:27 AM ET Rating closed on Jun. 16 2003, 2:02 PM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Hold
BCSB performance: Price near date of rating (06/04/2003): 16.39 Price near end of rating (06/16/2003): 15.65 Gain/Loss over 12 days: -0.74 -4.51% Annualized Gain/Loss: -137.18% This MHC has never made even average earnings. It's possible to grow the size of a bank and earnings at the same time. BCSB has not figured out how this is done. It's ok to hold some shares if you are buying a "basket" of MHC's, but I'd commit my major dollars to the better performers. Was this user's rating of 'BCSB' helpful to you?
back to top
-- CFFN --
CFFN	Nov. 26 2002, 10:04 AM ET Rating closed on Jun. 21 2003, 3:00 PM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Strong Buy
CFFN performance: Price near date of rating (11/26/2002): 27.14 Price near end of rating (06/23/2003): 28.25 Price change: +1.11 Dividends collected: 0.45 Gain/Loss over 206 days: +1.56 +5.75% Annualized Gain/Loss: +10.19% Buybacks, waived dividends including special dividends, dutch auction, low expense ratio, high ROA, low NPA, dominates their local market in traditional mortgage and deposit products. They should write the textbook for mutuals on how to manage their MHC post conversion. Was this user's rating of 'CFFN' helpful to you?
back to top
-- CFSL --
CFSL	Nov. 22 2002, 11:06 AM ET Rating closed on Jun. 18 2003, 6:03 PM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Hold
CFSL performance: Price near date of rating (11/22/2002): 19.30 Price near end of rating (06/18/2003): 21.50 Price change: +2.20 Dividends collected: 0.12 Gain/Loss over 207 days: +2.32 +12.02% Annualized Gain/Loss: +21.19% Good location. Management doesn't seem to care about maximizing shareholder value. Was this user's rating of 'CFSL' helpful to you?
back to top
-- CHEV --
CHEV	Jan. 18 2004, 10:54 AM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Buy
CHEV performance: Price near date of rating (01/20/2004): 15.38 Recent price (05/23/2016): 15.01 Price change: -0.37 Dividends collected: 4.70384 Gain/Loss over 7669 days: +4.33 +28.18% Annualized Gain/Loss: +1.34% [ Comments shared with private group only ]
back to top
-- CHFN --
CHFN	Nov. 22 2002, 11:01 AM ET Rating closed on Jun. 17 2003, 5:22 PM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Hold
CHFN performance: Price near date of rating (11/22/2002): 23.62 Price near end of rating (06/17/2003): 22.99 Price change: -0.63 Dividends collected: 0.16038 Gain/Loss over 206 days: -0.47 -1.99% Annualized Gain/Loss: -3.53% I think the easy money has already been made here. But I wouldn't bet against the Johnsons. Was this user's rating of 'CHFN' helpful to you?
back to top
-- CSBK --
CSBK	Mar. 5 2004, 4:28 PM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Buy
CSBK performance: Price near date of rating (05/11/2004): 12.08 Recent price (03/29/2018): 15.65 Price change: +3.57 Dividends collected: 3.41374 Gain/Loss over 7622 days: +6.98 +57.81% Annualized Gain/Loss: +2.77% [ Comments shared with private group only ]
back to top
-- FPTB --
FPTB	Dec. 22 2002, 10:40 PM ET Rating changed on Jan. 2 2003, 10:46 AM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Strong Buy
FPTB performance: Price near date of rating (12/23/2002): 16.42 Price near end of rating (01/02/2003): 16.81 Gain/Loss over 11 days: +0.39 +2.38% Annualized Gain/Loss: +78.97% Great location at below book value price. CK, by the way Pacific Trust is not an MHC. Was this user's rating of 'FPTB' helpful to you?
back to top
FPTB	Jan. 2 2003, 10:46 AM ET Rating closed on Jul. 14 2003, 10:32 AM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Strong Buy
FPTB performance: Price near date of rating (01/02/2003): 16.81 Price near end of rating (07/14/2003): 18.75 Price change: +1.94 Dividends collected: 0.11 Gain/Loss over 192 days: +2.05 +12.18% Annualized Gain/Loss: +23.15% Great location at below book value price. It's the most affordable bank stock west of the Sierra Nevada. Was this user's rating of 'FPTB' helpful to you?
back to top
-- GPT --
GPT	Jan. 23 2003, 3:32 PM ET Rating closed on Sep. 26 2003, 9:23 PM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Sell
GPT performance: Price near date of rating (05/21/2013): 30.00 Price near end of rating (05/21/2013): 30.00 Gain/Loss over 245 days: 0.00 0.00% Annualized Gain/Loss: 0.00% Hard to understand this stock. If they do such a good job underwriting, why are their non-performing assets so high? And why don't they have more reserves set aside to back them up? What will happen to them in a sustainted recession with a falling real estate market? My fear is that there is a lot more risk in their loan portfolio than is generally understood. Was this user's rating of 'GPT' helpful to you?
back to top
-- HCBK --
HCBK	Nov. 21 2002, 1:23 PM ET Rating closed on Sep. 26 2003, 9:27 PM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Buy
HCBK performance: Price near date of rating (11/21/2002): 5.91 Price near end of rating (09/26/2003): 9.47 Price change: +3.56 Dividends collected: 0.11541 Gain/Loss over 308 days: +3.68 +62.19% Annualized Gain/Loss: +73.70% CK took the words out of my mouth. Everyone should own some HCBK and CFFN. Hudson City might be the best savings bank franchise period. Was this user's rating of 'HCBK' helpful to you?
back to top
-- MCBF --
MCBF	Jan. 23 2003, 11:31 AM ET Rating closed on Sep. 26 2003, 9:27 PM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Hold
MCBF performance: Price near date of rating (01/23/2003): 11.57 Price near end of rating (09/26/2003): 14.78 Price change: +3.21 Dividends collected: 0.15 Gain/Loss over 245 days: +3.36 +29.04% Annualized Gain/Loss: +43.26% This bank came public so ugly, that I can't help but think that managment didn't clean it up first so that they could buy in cheap themselves. Look for the results to improve after the option prices are set and for them to sell out at a big gain after a few years. See close neighbors SFBI and Michigan City for other examples of this "bad is good" strategy. Was this user's rating of 'MCBF' helpful to you?
back to top
-- MO --
MO	Nov. 23 2002, 12:46 AM ET Rating closed on Aug. 13 2003, 5:58 PM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Strong Sell
MO performance: Price near date of rating (11/25/2002): 37.57 Price near end of rating (08/13/2003): 40.35 Price change: +2.78 Dividends collected: 1.92 Gain/Loss over 262 days: +4.70 +12.51% Annualized Gain/Loss: +17.43% I'm with Joac on this one. MO is an evil company. I know, CK that this country was founded on tabacco, but its been causing human death and suffering for centuries. Invest your money where it will do some good for humanity. Would George Bailey invest in big tabacco when he could be providing housing for the Martino family? If you own this, enjoy the high dividend cause in the end any remaining value will end up in the hands of the trial attorneys and governments. Was this user's rating of 'MO' helpful to you?
back to top
-- PFS --
PFS	Jan. 16 2003, 2:33 PM ET Rating closed on Sep. 3 2003, 2:24 PM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Hold
PFS performance: Price near date of rating (01/16/2003): 15.50 Price near end of rating (09/03/2003): 20.62 Price change: +5.12 Dividends collected: 0.09 Gain/Loss over 229 days: +5.21 +33.61% Annualized Gain/Loss: +53.57% A solid hold at this price level. In the unlikely event it fell below 14, I would be a strong buyer. Was this user's rating of 'PFS' helpful to you?
back to top
-- PHSB --
PHSB	Jan. 6 2003, 10:31 AM ET Rating closed on Sep. 26 2003, 9:30 PM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Hold
PHSB performance: Price near date of rating (01/06/2003): 15.88 Price near end of rating (09/26/2003): 18.61 Price change: +2.73 Dividends collected: 0.3 Gain/Loss over 262 days: +3.03 +19.08% Annualized Gain/Loss: +26.58% A solid hold at this price. If the price was a little lower or the bank was a little more profitable, I would move to a buy. Was this user's rating of 'PHSB' helpful to you?
back to top
-- RFBK --
RFBK	Apr. 17 2003, 10:37 AM ET Rating closed on Sep. 26 2003, 9:30 PM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Strong Buy
RFBK performance: Price near date of rating (10/07/2003): 13.00 Price near end of rating (10/07/2003): 13.00 Gain/Loss over 162 days: 0.00 0.00% Annualized Gain/Loss: 0.00% Hold your nose and buy some shares of this downstate Illinois micro-pig if you can find any. The stock is in strong hands. New managment has cleaned house and will be held accountable by OTS memorandum of understanding. It ain't very pretty, but hold on for the ride, it should be very profitable! Was this user's rating of 'RFBK' helpful to you?
back to top
-- RSLN --
RSLN	Nov. 21 2002, 3:07 PM ET Rating closed on Sep. 26 2003, 9:31 PM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Hold
RSLN performance: Price near date of rating (11/21/2002): 18.16 Price near end of rating (09/26/2003): 23.67 Price change: +5.51 Dividends collected: 0.6 Gain/Loss over 308 days: +6.11 +33.65% Annualized Gain/Loss: +39.88% [ No comment ] Was this user's rating of 'RSLN' helpful to you?
back to top
-- SERC --
SERC	Nov. 22 2002, 11:41 AM ET Rating closed on Sep. 26 2003, 9:31 PM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Hold
SERC performance: Price near date of rating (11/22/2002): 16.95 Price near end of rating (09/26/2003): 24.50 Gain/Loss over 307 days: +7.55 +44.54% Annualized Gain/Loss: +52.95% Many possible remut partners. Sleepy managment should cut expense ratio and boost earnings. Was this user's rating of 'SERC' helpful to you?
back to top
-- SFFS --
SFFS	Jan. 7 2003, 11:40 AM ET Rating closed on Sep. 26 2003, 9:32 PM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Hold
SFFS performance: Price near date of rating (01/07/2003): 11.00 Price near end of rating (09/26/2003): 15.00 Price change: +4.00 Dividends collected: 0.15 Gain/Loss over 261 days: +4.15 +37.73% Annualized Gain/Loss: +52.76% A solid hold at these price levels. It's everything I like in a bank, good location, profitable, nice size, clean loan portfolio. If only I could buy it below book value. Was this user's rating of 'SFFS' helpful to you?
back to top
-- SYNF --
SYNF	Nov. 21 2002, 6:05 PM ET Rating closed on Jul. 19 2003, 10:21 AM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Strong Buy
SYNF performance: Price near date of rating (01/06/2003): 4.57 Price near end of rating (07/21/2003): 5.51 Gain/Loss over 239 days: +0.94 +20.57% Annualized Gain/Loss: +31.41% North Jersey MHC former credit union. Buyback, Waive, Remut. That's all you need to know. Was this user's rating of 'SYNF' helpful to you?
back to top
-- TONE --
TONE	Nov. 21 2002, 1:02 PM ET Rating closed on Jul. 2 2003, 2:58 PM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Hold
TONE performance: Price near date of rating (11/21/2002): 14.35 Price near end of rating (07/02/2003): 19.56 Gain/Loss over 222 days: +5.21 +36.31% Annualized Gain/Loss: +59.70% [ No comment ] Was this user's rating of 'TONE' helpful to you?
back to top
-- WAWL --
WAWL	Apr. 1 2004, 09:49 AM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Strong Buy
WAWL performance: Price near date of rating (04/01/2004): 12.95 Recent price (04/03/2018): 3.95 Price change: -9.00 Dividends collected: 1.735 Gain/Loss over 7595 days: -7.26 -56.10% Annualized Gain/Loss: -2.70% [ Comments shared with private group only ]
back to top
-- WGBC --
WGBC	Jan. 1 2003, 3:38 PM ET Rating closed on Sep. 26 2003, 9:25 PM ET	by Jimmybodeen (view profile)	rating: Sell
WGBC performance: Price near date of rating (01/02/2003): 13.80 Price near end of rating (09/26/2003): 16.08 Price change: +2.28 Dividends collected: 0.25 Gain/Loss over 267 days: +2.53 +18.33% Annualized Gain/Loss: +25.06% I agree with Joac. Take your profits and move on to some of the higher rated stocks here. Was this user's rating of 'WGBC' helpful to you?
back to top

Nothing in BankInvestor.com is intended to be investment advice, nor does it represent the opinion of, counsel from, or recommendations by Bankinvestor.com. ©2025 info@bankinvestor.com About Us Contact Us How To Privacy Policy Terms Of Use
www.bankinvestor.com is the premier online investment club with a focus on and after-market bank investing opportunities. Site content powered in part by stock ticker and financial content provider, TickerTech.com. Be sure to look at our sister site for stock market message boards, trading tips and research, ValueForum.com.