Log on |  Join ($$)
	search discussion:

These ratings are posted by site users; this content is not intended to be investment advice, nor does it represent the opinion of, counsel from, or recommendations by Bankinvestor.com

Average returns on belowbookvalue's ratings: Rating Avg. Return Annualized Key: - : rated buy, stock went down + : rated sell, stock went up +/- : rated hold + : rated buy, stock went up - : rated sell, stock went down strong buy +2.64% (over an avg. of 5023.33 days) +0.19% buy +16.85% (over an avg. of 198.00 days) +31.06% hold -32.01% (over an avg. of 7400.33 days) -1.58% sell +8.63% (over an avg. of 72.00 days) +43.75% strong sell +4.21% (over an avg. of 3760.50 days) +0.41% -- See performance by time period -- All ratings made during the year 2003 All ratings made during the year 2004 Ratings made during Apr, 2003 Ratings made during May, 2003 Ratings made during Jun, 2003 Ratings made during Jul, 2003 Ratings made during Sep, 2003 Ratings made during Oct, 2003 Ratings made during Jan, 2004 Ratings made during Feb, 2004 Ratings made during Apr, 2004 Ratings made during May, 2004

Jump to rating for: ANE   BCSB   BKMU   FTCG   JFBI   JFSZ   PRTR   SKBO  

NOTE: areas highlighted in blue indicate that this user is sharing the highlighted information with their private group ONLY

-- ANE --
ANE	Feb. 9 2004, 9:49 PM ET Rating changed on Apr. 2 2004, 7:49 PM ET	by belowbookvalue (view profile)	rating: Strong Sell
ANE performance: Price near date of rating (05/24/2006): 5.40 Price near end of rating (05/24/2006): 5.40 Gain/Loss over 53 days: 0.00 0.00% Annualized Gain/Loss: 0.00% [ Comments shared with private group only ]
back to top
ANE	Apr. 2 2004, 7:49 PM ET Rating changed on Apr. 3 2004, 07:59 AM ET	by belowbookvalue (view profile)	rating: Buy
ANE performance: Price near date of rating (05/24/2006): 5.40 Price near end of rating (05/24/2006): 5.40 Gain/Loss over 1 day: 0.00 0.00% Annualized Gain/Loss: 0.00% [ Comments shared with private group only ]
back to top
ANE	Apr. 3 2004, 07:59 AM ET Rating closed on Apr. 14 2004, 5:57 PM ET	by belowbookvalue (view profile)	rating: Buy
ANE performance: Price near date of rating (05/24/2006): 5.40 Price near end of rating (05/24/2006): 5.40 Gain/Loss over 10 days: 0.00 0.00% Annualized Gain/Loss: 0.00% [ Comments shared with private group only ]
back to top
-- BCSB --
BCSB	Apr. 29 2003, 06:52 AM ET Rating changed on Jul. 14 2003, 1:17 PM ET	by belowbookvalue (view profile)	rating: Strong Buy
BCSB performance: Price near date of rating (04/29/2003): 15.35 Price near end of rating (07/14/2003): 17.33 Price change: +1.98 Dividends collected: 0.125 Gain/Loss over 76 days: +2.10 +13.71% Annualized Gain/Loss: +65.84% 1) One of cheapest MHC available relative to initial pricing 2) Just announced strong earnings which are not reflected in pricing 3) Obvious acquisition target for NWSB which has already purchased Leeds MHC in same town. NWSB is also doing a partial offering of their stock. Will NWSB use this to pay off BCSB shareholders? Was this user's rating of 'BCSB' helpful to you? Currently:   0 said yes (of 1 -- 0.00%)
back to top
BCSB	Jul. 14 2003, 1:17 PM ET Rating changed on Jan. 28 2004, 5:47 PM ET	by belowbookvalue (view profile)	rating: Buy
BCSB performance: Price near date of rating (07/14/2003): 17.33 Price near end of rating (01/28/2004): 20.00 Price change: +2.67 Dividends collected: 0.25 Gain/Loss over 198 days: +2.92 +16.85% Annualized Gain/Loss: +31.06% Downgrading from Strong buy to Buy based on a $2 rise in stock price since last rating 1) One of cheapest MHC available relative to initial pricing 2) Obvious acquisition target for NWSB which has already purchased Leeds MHC in same town. NWSB is also doing a partial offering of their stock. Will NWSB use this to pay off BCSB shareholders? Was this user's rating of 'BCSB' helpful to you? Currently:   0 said yes (of 1 -- 0.00%)
back to top
BCSB	Jan. 28 2004, 5:47 PM ET	by belowbookvalue (view profile)	rating: Hold
BCSB performance: Price near date of rating (01/28/2004): 20.00 Recent price (02/14/2014): 24.68 Price change: +4.68 Dividends collected: 1.375 Gain/Loss over 7393 days: +6.05 +30.27% Annualized Gain/Loss: +1.49% Downgrading from Buy to Hold based on a $3 rise in stock price since last rating 1) Obvious acquisition target for NWSB which has already purchased Leeds MHC in same town. 2) Can not explain recent run although would welcome a 2nd step or buyout. Was this user's rating of 'BCSB' helpful to you? Currently:   0 said yes (of 1 -- 0.00%)
back to top
-- BKMU --
BKMU	Jan. 8 2004, 8:58 PM ET	by belowbookvalue (view profile)	rating: Strong Buy
BKMU performance: Price near date of rating (01/08/2004): 11.11 Recent price (02/01/2018): 10.40 Price change: -0.71 Dividends collected: 2.935 Gain/Loss over 7413 days: +2.23 +20.03% Annualized Gain/Loss: +0.99% Rating it on a $11.11 close 1/8/03. This is the time to buy BKMU surge of January tax selling has peaked. Look for a nice move into February. Jan 27 will be 90 days since conversion. Was this user's rating of 'BKMU' helpful to you? Currently:   1 said yes (of 4 -- 25.00%)
back to top
-- FTCG --
FTCG	Jul. 14 2003, 6:39 PM ET Rating changed on Jul. 23 2003, 12:43 PM ET	by belowbookvalue (view profile)	rating: Strong Sell
FTCG performance: Price near date of rating (07/14/2003): 51.30 Price near end of rating (07/23/2003): 50.93 Gain/Loss over 9 days: -0.37 -0.72% Annualized Gain/Loss: -29.20% [ Comments shared with private group only ]
back to top
FTCG	Jul. 23 2003, 12:43 PM ET Rating changed on Oct. 2 2003, 3:06 PM ET	by belowbookvalue (view profile)	rating: Sell
FTCG performance: Price near date of rating (07/23/2003): 50.93 Price near end of rating (10/02/2003): 58.05 Price change: +7.12 Dividends collected: 0.19 Gain/Loss over 71 days: +7.31 +14.35% Annualized Gain/Loss: +73.77% [ Comments shared with private group only ]
back to top
FTCG	Oct. 2 2003, 3:06 PM ET	by belowbookvalue (view profile)	rating: Strong Sell
FTCG performance: Price near date of rating (10/02/2003): 58.05 Recent price (10/31/2003): 63.35 Gain/Loss over 7512 days: +5.30 +9.13% Annualized Gain/Loss: +0.44% [ Comments shared with private group only ]
back to top
-- JFBI --
JFBI	Jul. 25 2003, 09:21 AM ET	by belowbookvalue (view profile)	rating: Strong Buy
JFBI performance: Price near date of rating (07/25/2003): 12.80 Recent price (05/30/2014): 8.02 Price change: -4.78 Dividends collected: 1.475 Gain/Loss over 7581 days: -3.31 -25.82% Annualized Gain/Loss: -1.24% Strong earnings report this morning merits JFBI to be trading over $14 in very near future. http://biz.yahoo.com/bw/030725/255161_1.html Was this user's rating of 'JFBI' helpful to you?
back to top
-- JFSZ --
JFSZ	May. 2 2003, 06:59 AM ET Rating closed on Jul. 14 2003, 1:12 PM ET	by belowbookvalue (view profile)	rating: Sell
JFSZ performance: Price near date of rating (05/02/2003): 47.44 Price near end of rating (07/01/2003): 48.50 Price change: +1.06 Dividends collected: 0.325 Gain/Loss over 73 days: +1.39 +2.92% Annualized Gain/Loss: +14.60% Sell leaning to hold. Negative: Yields just over 1%, Yahoo and Pink Sheet boards indicate no earnings Is a long way from where it started at $10 a couple years ago (now $46.50) Similar to FNFG immediately before second step: Inflated stock that foundered. FNFG eventually made new highs several months after second step. Second Step is managed by KBW- I do not look for it to be attractive. Positive: With only 17% of company publicly traded, Existing shareholders will get the wind at their back of 83% of company converting. Was this user's rating of 'JFSZ' helpful to you? Currently:   0 said yes (of 1 -- 0.00%)
back to top
-- PRTR --
PRTR	Apr. 14 2004, 6:06 PM ET Rating changed on May. 22 2004, 09:22 AM ET	by belowbookvalue (view profile)	rating: Sell
PRTR performance: Price near date of rating (05/09/2007): 1.01 Price near end of rating (05/09/2007): 1.01 Gain/Loss over 38 days: 0.00 0.00% Annualized Gain/Loss: 0.00% [ Comments shared with private group only ]
back to top
PRTR	May. 22 2004, 09:22 AM ET	by belowbookvalue (view profile)	rating: Hold
PRTR performance: Price near date of rating (05/09/2007): 1.01 Recent price (12/29/2022): 0.11 Gain/Loss over 7279 days: -0.90 -89.11% Annualized Gain/Loss: -4.47% [ Comments shared with private group only ]
back to top
-- SKBO --
SKBO	May. 29 2003, 11:44 AM ET Rating changed on Jun. 6 2003, 11:37 AM ET	by belowbookvalue (view profile)	rating: Strong Buy
SKBO performance: Price near date of rating (02/16/2006): 25.00 Price near end of rating (02/16/2006): 25.00 Gain/Loss over 8 days: 0.00 0.00% Annualized Gain/Loss: 0.00% This is the MHC for First Carnegie Deposit of Pittsburgh. Assets are about $150 M. Initial offering was October, 1998. Currently trading @ $14. Reasons I like it: 1) 60% mutually held gives it good dividend waive power 2) Generous dividend policy with numerous extraordinary dividends 3) Current dividend is $.48/ year 4) Chairman is 75 5) In NWSB territory - NWSB is coming into a lot of cash very soon - They have bought other MHC- - I believe SKBO is target 6) In event of second step you will see nice pop on announcement and actual conversion. 7) No bubble in their assets 8) Cheaply priced relative to other MHC Was this user's rating of 'SKBO' helpful to you? Currently:   0 said yes (of 1 -- 0.00%)
back to top
SKBO	Jun. 6 2003, 11:37 AM ET Rating changed on Sep. 15 2003, 10:59 AM ET	by belowbookvalue (view profile)	rating: Strong Buy
SKBO performance: Price near date of rating (02/16/2006): 25.00 Price near end of rating (02/16/2006): 25.00 Gain/Loss over 101 days: 0.00 0.00% Annualized Gain/Loss: 0.00% This is the MHC for First Carnegie Deposit of Pittsburgh. Assets are about $150 M. Initial offering was October, 1998. Currently trading @ $13.08 -- Proof that the market has moments of irrationality. Reasons I like it: 1) 60% mutually held gives it good dividend waive power 2) Generous dividend policy with numerous extraordinary dividends 3) Current dividend is $.48/ year 4) Chairman is 75 5) In NWSB territory - NWSB is coming into a lot of cash very soon - They have bought other MHC- - I believe SKBO is target 6) In event of second step you will see nice pop on announcement and actual conversion. 7) No bubble in their assets 8) Cheaply priced relative to other MHC Was this user's rating of 'SKBO' helpful to you? Currently:   0 said yes (of 1 -- 0.00%)
back to top
SKBO	Sep. 15 2003, 10:59 AM ET	by belowbookvalue (view profile)	rating: Hold
SKBO performance: Price near date of rating (02/16/2006): 25.00 Recent price (06/25/2009): 15.70 Gain/Loss over 7529 days: -9.30 -37.20% Annualized Gain/Loss: -1.80% Downgrading from a strong buy to a hold based on announced merger with NWSB @ $17. Holders can look forward to a .7% appreciation upon consummation. This is the MHC for First Carnegie Deposit of Pittsburgh. Assets are about $150 M. Initial offering was October, 1998. Currently trading @ $16.87-- Reasons I liked it before merger announcement: 1) 60% mutually held gives it good dividend waive power 2) Generous dividend policy with numerous extraordinary dividends 3) Current dividend is $.48/ year 4) Chairman is 75 5) In NWSB territory - NWSB is coming into a lot of cash very soon - They have bought other MHC- - I believe SKBO is target 6) In event of second step you will see nice pop on announcement and actual conversion. 7) No bubble in their assets 8) Cheaply priced relative to other MHC Best possible scenario for stockholders and some other interested parties is that SKBO cancels merger and pursues second step conversion- likelihood is nero zero. Was this user's rating of 'SKBO' helpful to you? Currently:   0 said yes (of 1 -- 0.00%)
back to top

Nothing in BankInvestor.com is intended to be investment advice, nor does it represent the opinion of, counsel from, or recommendations by Bankinvestor.com. ©2024 info@bankinvestor.com About Us Contact Us How To Privacy Policy Terms Of Use
www.bankinvestor.com is the premier online investment club with a focus on and after-market bank investing opportunities. Site content powered in part by stock ticker and financial content provider, TickerTech.com. Be sure to look at our sister site for stock market message boards, trading tips and research, ValueForum.com.